I’m showing my ignorance, but would appreciate the opportunity to learn from you.1) 2.7A x 120V = 324W being handled by the transformer, coupled between leads by winding. That isn't dissipation by the transformer.
Dissipation might be 1% of that for light load. At full load, maybe 5% or possibly 10%.
My logic was that 2.7A flowing through the coil of the Autotransformer translates to 324W flowing through the transformer that otherwise would being going out to the utility pole.
I guess your point is that the majority of that power of flowing out to the load so only 1% or less is getting lost as heat in the Autotransformer itself, correct?
I^2R losses would probably be the easiest way to calculate energy lost to heat but I’m not finding any spec on wire size used in these Autotransformers.
The Solis Autotransformer is rated for a maximum of 30A, so that must mean at least 12AWG, but without any idea of wire length, it’s not possible to translate that AWG into coil resistance.
Full load of 30A would translate to 900R Watts being lost when maxed out @ 3.6kW, so 5% would be 180W or 0.2 Ohms of resistance in the coil while 10% would be 360W and 0.4 Ohms of coil resistance.
So 2.7A translates to 1.46-2.9W of losses when 324W are being balanced, so 0.5-0.9%. Understand and thanks.
Yes, understand. The power loss is immaterial and really nothing to worry about unless the Autotransformer is frequently being maxed out…If it is a 3kW transformer handling 300W, maybe it dissipated 3W.
If handling 10x the watts, 3000W, and 10x the current, power dissipation in windings goes as current squared, so could be 100x the dissipation, 300W dissipated.
So hanging an Autotransformer off of the main panel or a critical loads subpanel with double-pole breakers sized for 30A will be safe as long as the wiring used is rated for 60A (6AWG).2) If the autotransformer has breakers sized for its rating, and if the wire(s) connecting its neutral have ampacity 2x that breaker rating, it won't be a hazard.
The whole narrative about ‘loops’ being formed with the utility pole transformer as well as the narrative about the Autotransformer and the utility pole transformer possible having slightly different numbers of windings to their center taps is really nothing to be concerned about, would you agree?
I’m not understanding this. In the example shown in the video I linked to, the Autotransformer was drawing ~324W from an imbalance being created by a 1.875kW hair dryer, do the Autotransformer was absorbing 17.3% of the imbalance and the other 82.7% was being handled by the utility pole transformer.If it does draw more current than it can handle (trying to balance the grid) it will trip the breaker protecting itself. Just make sure your 120V loads fed by the autotransformer also get disconnected along with it.
For whatever reason, the breaker to the Autotransformer trips - why is it important to disconnect the hairdryer? The Autotransformer is functioning no differently than a load on one leg and a source (inverter) on the other leg - I’m not understanding why it’s important to disconnect loads and if the breaker protecting the Autotransformer trips (when on grid)?
Off-grid is a different matter, but that’s not a priority for me (perfectly happy handling any backup needs at 120VAC only).
If an Autotransformer is sized to handle a multiple of maximum imbalance, it seems low power loss would be inconsequential and breaker will pretty much never get tripped. In my case 3 1.8kW loads running off me leg at the same time is a realistic worst-case for my imbalance, so 5.4kW of worst-case imbalance translating to less than 20% of what a 30kW Autotransformer can handle (less when grid-tied, since the majority of imbalance will be handled by the utility pole transformer).3) Exactly.
If my toroid transformers are 0.5% regulation like that data sheet I found, I think they are more likely to see over-current and trip the breaker. Conventional E-core transformer would have longer windings, looser regulation, less likely to overload itself. With load tests and considering voltage tolerance at which inverter disconnects from grid, I could probably determine which would happen first.
I’m now starting to think about the Victron Multiplus II 120Vx2. I’m perfectly fine with backing up at 120VAC only, so my critical loads panel consisting of 120VAC only loads can be served by the same 120VAC backup power on both legs (just make sure there are no branch circuits)If someone has a 120V inverter, auto-transformer could be safely used to get 120/240V split-phase on the output.
My bigger concern is grid-side load offset when grid tied.
With no Autotransformer, the Multiplus II 120x2 will be exporting power on one leg sufficient to offset consumption on the other leg.
So at 240VAC, consumption will be zero, but there will up to 3kW being exported on one leg to balance up to 3kW being consumed on the other leg.
On a more practical basis, when my 3kW heating element from my 240V electric oven fires, the inverter will push a full 3kW out of it’ AC input, resulting in 1.5kW being exported on the inverted leg while 1.5kW is being imported/consumed on the other leg.
I’d consider adding an Autotransformer if that would get both legs down to 0kW being imported or exported, but any Autotransformer is only going to handle a percentage of the imbalance when grid-tied, so it’s really not adding much of anything.
Exporting 1.24kW on the inverted leg really isn’t any different than exporting 1.5kW (and the 240VAC consumption is going to be 0kW in either case…
With a 240V single-phase inverter (european model), auto-transformer on input could make 240V, and auto-transformer on output could make 120V.
While grid-tied, the biggest advantage I see for 240VAC versus 120VAC is that my existing grid-tied PV is 240VAC (Microinverters) so a 24VAC AIO with ability to charge a battery from 240VAC can absorb any excess solar production beyond that needed to serve loads without adding imbalance.
But since the loads will not be balanced, zeroing-out export will result in one leg having export while the other leg has offsetting import in any case. So I’m really not seeing any advantage to a 240VAC hybrid system over a 120VAC hybrid system when grid tied.
And when off-grid, 120VAC is easer for backing up 120VAC only than doing so from 240VAC.
The only advantage I see to a 240VAC hybrid is if you want to back up 240VAC and 120VAC loads (in which case you should really go with a split-phase hybrid).
You can go single-phase 120VAC or 240VAC with an Autotransformer but then you do need to pay attention to what happens when the breaker protecting the Autotransformer trips (especially if serving 120V loads from 240VAC with an Autotransformer.
I’m curious whether you see any negatives to 120VAC hybrids used to offset split-phase consumption (when on-grid).
The only one I’ve come up with is that the currents being injected into the main panel will be twice as high when inverting 3kW to 120VAC rather than 240VAC (though 25A seems pretty manageable).