I am glad I was not the only one to have this theory. I legit typed the same exact hypothesis to Ben. I agree I believe it "remembers" being below threshold and will not revert until setting 13 is hit. Because Solar interrupted that process, it was sending all the solar to the battery and remaining in bypass, but because Solar is priority for charging, the AC In was shutoff until Solar stopped producing.
Because I am very interested in testing this hypothesis, I am letting it grid charge to 54V. It's at 53.7 now so I should have my answer before I go to sleep.