• Have you tried out dark mode?! Scroll to the bottom of any page to find a sun or moon icon to turn dark mode on or off!

diy solar

diy solar

Lawsuit challenging Alabama Power solar panel charge

Electric grid and road network are part of basic infrastructure in any society and have to be paid for somehow - if not by user fees then by taxes.
No man is an island.
Edit: Think of it as part of the overhead cost of living in a first world country.
 
Last edited:
I took note of:
- the fee madness that took over the world a few decades back (another way to grab more money, and which might have been started by the airlines?)
- smart meters (it's for *your* benefit)
- contracts with both your local grid/co-op AND with your state PUC (yes we can come onto your property and into your home, and yes we can cut your power for any reason)

and determined that the only thing to do was go off-grid. We purchased land in a rural area of Southern Colorado, and are fully off-grid. No more fees, base and extended charges, taxes, smart meter claws, hacks into the system, etc.

And, as if all that old madness wasn't enough, now there's new madness:

- local governments and grids determining that "it is unsafe to keep the power on, so you are SOL" (landslide folks in LA, wildfires, etc.)

The madness pretty much stopped when we went off-grid ...

It's really the only answer to old and new forms of such madness ...
 
Wow. So they've done a complete 180. Instead of net metering, they are charging you for exporting your power to the grid.

More reason to go off grid. Over the life of your solar system, you'll save more than enough to buy some big ass batteries.
 
Wow. So they've done a complete 180. Instead of net metering, they are charging you for exporting your power to the grid.

More reason to go off grid. Over the life of your solar system, you'll save more than enough to buy some big ass batteries.
They want to charge you for what you own: solar panels and batteries regardless if you sell back or not.
 
Discussing the situation by including a mixture of billing practices from around the country isn't fruitful. It's more useful to hear your company's billing practices as AntronX did.
Just FWIW an example of a coop bill. I have found it's a common (and strange) practice for them to not state $/kwh, but it is $0.1215/kwh. Base charge goes to $35/mo 1/1/25 after they found out their buddies were all getting away with that...

Screenshot_20241012_062233_OneDrive.jpg
 
That grid *connection* (umbilical cord) is what allows "just about anything we can dream up" in terms of new ways to grab money. Because of the connection, and the local and state contracts you sign to get service, you will pay out more money, and you *will* like it!

Only way to sever the cost and fee increases is to cut that key connection ...

If I were to go back on grid (and I never will again, having enjoyed freedom from the grid for over a decade now), I'd be putting in a parallel off-grid system, and then one day, cutting that cord ...
 
You mean like the monthly service connection fee? The one you have to pay regardless of how many watts you use?
ohhh... there be worse systems there Rednecktk! Like the ones here in Japan.... its broken down to how many amps you can (not actually) take. so 30 amp service is like xxxx yen per month then there are tier breaks at 40, 50 , 60, 80, 100, and 120. not sure if there is anything higher as I ran like a scalded dog when I got the monthly bill for the 120 amp service and backed it down to 80.(presolar) it was about 50 USD per month even if I was not there and not using a single watt... and to tie a solar system in, you can only put a system in that matches your consumption tier , so if like me you have 8k of panels on the roof, you need to have service that can handle that much export at 100 volts in other words an 80 amp service even if you do not consume that much. so we get wanged with a 30 USD at todays spot rate even though the most I could hope to pull is about 50 amps with everything running at the same time. if I was not planning on renting the hosue when i retire, i would disconnnect and just run off batteries like my cabin.... but once i rent it it needs to have grid tie.
 
I agree that there should be a fee to maintain the grid infrastructure, storm repair fund, and administration cost. Ideally the utility can base this information of past use by the individual as well as people in that area.

It should be what is in the connection fee..
All other costs targeting solar panels are nothing more than profit protect for the power company
The part that I question is if I want to over panel and have excessive storage to reduce my dependency on the grid why should I have to pay the grid more. The fees mentioned above shouldn't be base on how many KW of panels or KWH of battery I have. My possessions shouldn't be factored into the calculation. That is a wealth tax at that point.

Now if the end user has massive surge current to charge a massive tone of batteries that should be charged a premium for unexpected high demand for their use of the grid.
 
Should power grid be a social responsibility?
No.

A highway runs by my business. With socialism I should get a fee from every vehicle, horse and buggy and bicycle that passes by my business regardless of whether they ever use my services. I should also get a fee for every aircraft that flies over my business.
 
Base charge goes to $35/mo 1/1/25 after they found out their buddies were all getting away with that...
It's a trend everywhere. We have $25 minimum bill if you use too little kWh. This is due to behind the meter solar.
Like the ones here in Japan.... its broken down to how many amps you can (not actually) take.
This seems fair. You get backup power to slowly charge your batteries and PoCo gets a guarantee that you will never need a lot of amps so they don't have to maintain reserve capacity for you.
 
No.

A highway runs by my business. With socialism I should get a fee from every vehicle, horse and buggy and bicycle that passes by my business regardless of whether they ever use my services. I should also get a fee for every aircraft that flies over my business.
under "pure socialism" you don't own a business, or property. the state owns everything, and you are just a member of the state.
There are really no pure socialist or pure capitalist societies anywhere. They are all a mix of both.
If we had a "pure capitalist" society one corporation would end up owning everything eventually. Like Costco in the Idiocracy movie, or Buy-n-Large corp in Wall-E.
 
It's a trend everywhere. We have $25 minimum bill if you use too little kWh. This is due to behind the meter solar.

This seems fair. You get backup power to slowly charge your batteries and PoCo gets a guarantee that you will never need a lot of amps so they don't have to maintain reserve capacity for you.
yes but you are limited to how many you can produce and the numbers never really work in your favor. battery backup just becasme a thing here in the last 5 years, a friend just bought a full system for his new construction house. it was about 30k for a 6kw system with 18kw backup battery and the japanese version of solar assistant (not the same but similar).
 
That fee does not cover the cost of operating the grid. With my utility it costs around 8 cents/kWh with final out of pocket cost to me at $0.15/kWh. Fuel is 2.7 cents/kWh and the rest is taxes around 2 c/kWh.
Actually your 100% wrong. I have 3 homes.

House 1 : No one lives there anymore. I kept the power on but it uses 0 watts a month. I pay $15 or so for the privilege of having power there.

House 2 and 3 have panels and I pay a power bill on them.

The fee house 1 cost me is ALL they are entitled to whether I have solar panels or not.

If that $15 or so is good enough there then its good enough at the other houses too.

Now if you want to sell to the grid then by all means have fees but if I am not selling to the grid then what I do with solar is none of their business.
 
This sounds like one of those great ideas to collect money after they told everyone to "conserve energy"
Michigan is complaining that they aren't getting enough money anymore for road taxes because of electric vehicles not buying gas (where the tax is) so they want to charge everyone based off their odometer.... "oh you racked up 10000 miles, surely it was all in Michigan so you need to pay for that"
Minnesota added a "MN Road Improvement" tax when you order something online precisely for this.
 
That's because there are plenty of other customers to pick up the tab. Run a scenario where everyone only pays $15.
Doesn't work that way. You can't change the price per gallon for gas at the gas station just because they think I might not come back often enough to buy more gas. You can raise the cost of gas for everyone but not just for a few people based on they might not shop there enough.

Also if they do loose the case against the fee they are charging I hope a smart lawyer sues them class action style for those of us with batteries. Having batteries reduces the cost of the power the companies pay based on their argument since load is being lowered during the night. So if they can charge a fee because of cost increase they should be liable for the savings solar users are providing them in return :)

Since its now out of the public service commissions hands the power company will lose in the long run I would imagine. The public service commission is packed with people the power company got put in place. As long as they could keep it inside their system they could pull this off. So the odds are good they are screwed now. Hoping for the best.
 
That's because there are plenty of other customers to pick up the tab. Run a scenario where everyone only pays $15.
I'm having a hard time reading your posts. Are you cheerleading for the power companies?

Per your own words, they are government protected monopolies. They have been milking everybody for years, they don't deserve more at our expense for their increasingly shoddy services. If they don't like the profits they are currently getting, it should be taken from them entirely and the government can run it directly so no profits go to anybody (conceptually).

I would much rather electric utility operation come directly out of taxes to be run as a non profit than it be privatized with socialized losses and privatized profit.
 
I'm having a hard time reading your posts. Are you cheerleading for the power companies?

Per your own words, they are government protected monopolies. They have been milking everybody for years, they don't deserve more at our expense for their increasingly shoddy services. If they don't like the profits they are currently getting, it should be taken from them entirely and the government can run it directly so no profits go to anybody (conceptually).

I would much rather electric utility operation come directly out of taxes to be run as a non profit than it be privatized with socialized losses and privatized profit.
it was more like they have the base meter fee. we (I) don't want to give them any more. They should tax me on my personal property that I own (solar/batteries) just what I use and the base fee that pays to maintain grid.
 
I would much rather electric utility operation come directly out of taxes to be run as a non profit than it be privatized with socialized losses and privatized profit.
no gawd no...you theink the power companies are screwed? have you ever in your entire life seen the government run something that actually worked even semi somewhat properly? Think DMV, think the VA hospitals, look at congress and the senate! hell no...
 
no gawd no...you theink the power companies are screwed? have you ever in your entire life seen the government run something that actually worked even semi somewhat properly? Think DMV, think the VA hospitals, look at congress and the senate! hell no...
I can name private companies I've had to deal with that are just as awful. The only real difference is that in some rare cases, I have a choice of whether I deal with the private companies.. not much of one, but sometimes there is a competitor that is slightly less awful. With something like the DMV, obviously there is no choice, and you have to suck it up.

Since the electric utilities are a protected monopoly that don't have to compete in a free market, they should happily accept the gravy train they've had for years and STFU.
 

diy solar

diy solar
Back
Top