I need writing to clarify what I did and why. Please bare with me.
Backstory
I had some panels on a roof in an east-west orientation that did not quite cover my electricity consumption (they did about half) so I wanted more.
I do have some more roof surface facing south (top right of photo) which would be ideal but that is on the main house and the wife has a particular opinion about aesthetics which renders most of that surface unusable. The next best thing was a narrow strip at the edge of the property, the looks of which she declared not to care about. So an in-line groundmount it would have to be.
I started looking at off-the-shelf groundmount solutions for solar panels and soon found that even the cheaper ones would cost me more than all electrical components combined, which seemed pointless, so I would have to make my own rackmount. After comparing material options it appeared that steel would still be rather expensive and for most of the available beam types, impractical. Whatever I could get as reclaimed parts was either not enough, too heavy or more than I needed and still expensive. It would have to be timber for me.
I had about 18 meters to spare but not much depth. I should have taken a picture before I started building, here's the earliest one I have. Note the electric fence along the grass border. At the far end along the back of the shed it gets even narrower.
The theoretical average yearly optimum tilt angle for my latitude would be problematic. Considering my east-west set covered my usage most of the summertime and the new set was to fill the gap in wintertime, I would be better off with a more vertical mount anyway. My initial thought was to just fix them in between poles, totally vertical. This would require the least mounting material, would be quick and easy to build and certainly could not be any cheaper. This would give me relatively good yields on the darkest days when the sun is low in the sky. In retrospect this still seems like a good idea. What kept me from doing this was my fear of storms. I am out in the fields, we do get the occasional storm and I had a particular type of pole in mind that did not convince me strengthwise without some kind of structure. Of course I could have just gone for thicker poles, like 10 cm square ones. On the other hand I would loose some yield and a slight tilt would allow me to build a rack with triangles which would be a lot stronger, given reasonably sized poles and beams. A 60 degree angle seemed like the sweet spot, this is what I ultimately went for.
Clearing the Site
Tree branches were hanging over the strip where the rack was to be build, into the neighbor's field. It was time for some serious pruning anyway. Some of the branches almost touched the grass and inhibited mowing. The neighboring field is for grass production and grazing. The neighbor had not complained yet but given the situation he had every right to. I had to cut a lot, not just to make room for the cows and the mower but also to not obscure the sun during summer. And then there was my beloved wife again complicating things by expressing she did not want me to be too radical. Every thick branch became a negotiation. But in the end it looked like we had a clear path for the build, the sun and the marriage.
Requirements
I set the following requirements for myself:
- Cheap
- Durable
- Nice looking
- Technically robust (no optimizers)
The cheap requirement was more of a sport thing than a necessity. It just feels more like a win to me if I can get a quick ROI.
Durability pertains mainly to the rack. It was going to be wood and I did not want to see it rot away within a couple of years.
When I drive up to my home the array would be very visible so I wanted it to look good. To me this means all black panels and preferrably no visible nuts or bolts.
My existing system is a SolarEdge one, installed in 2016. I have had about half of the optimizers fail on me since. They gave me headaches, considerable downtime and a lot of work. Their benefits have been proven questionable at best, the whole experience put me off regarding the brand and the technology.
Gear
So, after doing a fair amount of reading I ended up buying 16 Hyundai-HG-435Wp-PERCIUM-Shingled-Full-Black panels totalling 6960 Wp and a 5000 Watt Goodwe inverter. I did not expect to ever saturate the inverter given the 60 degree angle. I considered buying the "battery ready" version inverter that Goodwe offers which would have been 900 Euros instead of 600 Euros. The supported battery brands are limited though and would I ever make use of it? I figured if the time would ever come, I would be better off selling or repurposing that plain inverter and buying whatever would be most appropriate by then. Or go with an AC coupled system which would make the whole consideration moot. So I settled for the plain one, a GW5000-DNS-30.
Rack Construction
I started with 15 68x68 mm poles measuring 3 meters in length. 270 cm might have done also. The latter is the more common length in my area. With a bit of trigonometry and Pythagoras I figured out a workable way to get one shorter front pole and one longer back pole out of a single 3 meter pole, such that each part goes into the ground the same number of centimeters and the 60 degree slopes at the top align perfectly. In my case this meant putting the front and back poles 60 cm apart. The distance of these pole sets apart from each other (in the long direction) are to be chosen taking into account the stiffness of the horizontal bars to be fixed on the poles and the panel width plus gap width. You do not want the rims of a panel to align with a pole set if your choice of fixing relies on putting a bolt through the horizontal layers. In my case 125 cm seemed workable.
To get the 60 degree angles you need to first cut the pole at a right angle because a miter saw cannot cut more that 45 degrees midway. With an adaptor it can saw sharper angles from beam ends. YouTube has several instructional videos up on how to do that.
Your timber will be most sensitive to degradation at ground level and somewhat further down depending on the type of soil and wetness. In most cases you would want some kind of protection. My poles were of the greenish, impregnated with arsenic stuff type. I know from experience this only helps a little for a couple of years so I added a layer of black tar. I am not sure about the translation here. The stuff I used was disappointing, more on that later. There are better solutions, sleaves that can be shrunk onto the pole with a blow torch. I found these too expensive though so I will rely on prayers instead.
I placed the poles as accurate as I could, first puting some sticks in the ground for reference, marking them all at the same height using a laser level. You should not assume your ground is level over the length of your rack. If you don't have the laser level you can use a transparent hose with water or a long straight aluminium beam (that I cannot find the proper English word for) and tape a spirit level to it. This will be less acurate because you will need several hops but then again, we are not building a Hadron collider. You best place the fist pole sets further apart so you can look past them to get the inner sets aligned. I used a simple manual auger to drill holes in the ground. If the soil is really dry or sandy your hole will be filled again as you pull up the auger. A bit of water will make it better. You may need to widen the hole a couple of times and kick the pole a bit to get it both in line and straight up (use a spirit level).
If you did well you should be able to put beams on the sloping parts of the poles in a straight line without wandering off. I used long (100 mm) screws and predrilled just the beam part.
Then you have to decide how you are going to fix your panels to the rack. You can do this the smart and easy way or the stupid and hard way. The latter yields a slightly better looking result and is more theft proof than the former. Whether this is worth the trouble is of course a personal matter.
The thing is, if you go the easy way, how you go about the rest of your build won't matter much. If you choose the hard way, you can easily make it extra hard to fix your panels. But let's build that rack first in the most defensive way possible.
[to be continued...]