diy solar

diy solar

Question About Preventing Grid Backfeed

🤷No idea but its an off-grid inverter capable of taking an ac input so seems to fit op's use case don't really care what they call it (magic sunshine machine)as long as it does what it needs too.
It's an off grid AIO.
Terminology is important to avoid confusion.
It's possible that it would meet their needs. But we haven't heard exactly what their needs are, yet. So, I can't really make any recommendations.
 
Having read thru the entire thread, my thought is there's a lack of discussion on 'smart meters'. The assumption seems to be that everyone has one, but how do you know if yours actually will tattle on you? We have to post our usage from the meter to the POCO web page every month, so ours aint 'that' smart 😀

Our meter is an Itron Centron CS1. Based on the technical reference guide for the meter, and the display on the unit, it has the 'non-detented register' module installed. The documentation says that module displays "the delivered energy plus the received energy". Any thoughts on what that actually means? Here's the tech manual if anyone's interested.

FWIW, the POCO would have required installing a new meter for $650, had we gone net-metering.


Thanks!

Jim

PS- Barring something unforeseen, we power up the panels pre-sunrise tomorrow. Been running for a week with the SA15k and SOKs connected to and powering the house via the grid pass-thru...
 
Last edited:
"the delivered energy plus the received energy"
Energy delivered = (+P)import, energy received = (-P) export pretty much means net metering.
The US is far to big a country to have any real form of smart meters that benefit the energy suppliers, In the UK smart meters run ZigBee communication so your meter speaks to your neighbours meter and the neighbours speaks to their neighbours so on and so forth till it reaches some form of antenna that can report back to the energy company but this also has a fatal flaw, WiFi can interfere with ZigBee bands so depending on WiFi density this doesn't work either.
 
Sorry tell a lie there is a us version
My first EAsuns 3kW (SRNE) units were called hybrid although they were grid as backup (GAB). No way to export and would act like a UPS. If battery or PV was insufficient a relay would pickup and the grid would bypass. Your loads were supplied by inverter or AC bypass but not both at the same time. While in AC bypass the inverter could operate as a battery charger alongside PV.

My next units were PowMr 3kW (SRNE) high voltage PV units also called hybrid. Almost the same as the low PV voltage EAsuns but it their case they could be selected to operate with inverter and grid working together without export (supposedly) to the AC out (no feed back to AC in). I do not run in this mode (called mixed function mode) because it potentially could export.

Unfortunately with the new sensitive utility meters detecting very low wattage export the POCO will come out and check your setup. If they see Solar panels they assume that the export was due to you running an unapproved interconnect. Some demand that you prove you are not. It is always hard to prove a negative.

Hybrid does not have a hard and fast definition though there are some folks that get upset by what thy think is misuse of the word.
 
Our meter is an Itron Centron CS1.
People are reading these with a raspberry pi and this tool.


And here is a guy reverse engineering one (don’t try this at home):
 
Last edited:
I only correct people on their terminology to avoid confusion.
The only time I might get upset about it. Is after 3 days of helping troubleshoot someone's system, finding out that they don't actually have what they thought they did. And the 3 days were a complete waste of time. And then I have to try and get them to forget everything discussed. And only remember the new information.
 
People are reading these with a raspberry pi and this tool.


And here is a guy reverse engineering one (don’t try this at home):
Interesting...I have a couple free pi's sitting around. Will put it on the project list. 👍. Thanks!

For now, we'll plan to do a 'Tim' tomorrow morning....throw the switch ON the PV, then OFF with the grid. Already have the Chargeverter and have prepared for the eventuality of it to be the only thing grid-tied.

Thanks!

Jim
 
Can you put some rough performance (quantitative) requirements around your use case? And budget range.

EDIT: And qualitative requirements expressed in terms of the applications (IE appliances and project goals) that you are plugging in.

As a basic feasibility check.

To be direct the vague description you have here makes me quite worried it is an infeasible unicorn. With numbers you can prove to me it's not, or I can explain to you the pitfalls.
My Emporia went in yesterday so I don't have hard numbers yet. My utility gives 15 minute interval kWh usage and my highest consumption hour in the last year was under 8kWh.

The two large items are a 40 amp stoven and a 30 amp dryer. Everything else is lights and plugs (standard stuff - microwave, occasional hair dryer, computers and electronic hardware, LED lights, etc.)

I don't think what I *need* is a unicorn, I think what I *want* most definitely is. I would love to have an inverter - or components - that is relatively small for PV (I'm only planning about 2.5kW solar) but has the ability to provide enough battery power (watts and amps wise) AND be able to supplement grid power during peak usage time. All without the risk of backfeeding the grid.
 
Interesting...I have a couple free pi's sitting around. Will put it on the project list. 👍. Thanks!
You’ll need an rtl-sdr usb dongle to receive the transmissions, and maybe a 900 mhz antenna, but the right length wire will do in a pinch.
they are really cheap
Search Utube for videos showing their meters being read. search rtlamr
 
Any grid-tied or hybrid system has the potential to export, even when set to not do so. Which will require an agreement with the utility company and inspection from the utility company and local authorities.
The only guarantee to not export is an off grid system.
 
....

I don't think what I *need* is a unicorn, I think what I *want* most definitely is. I would love to have an inverter - or components - that is relatively small for PV (I'm only planning about 2.5kW solar) but has the ability to provide enough battery power (watts and amps wise) AND be able to supplement grid power during peak usage time. All without the risk of backfeeding the grid.
It is a matter of understanding that supplying loads from your solar setup can work alongside the grid (not in parallel or grid tied) or it can work with the grid. For instance you can wire a standard DC to AC inverter directly to a load. It is not connected to the grid. No possibility of grid export exists. You can even wire that inverter to a transfer switch with one supply being the inverter and the alternative supply being the grid. From the Transfer switch (MTS or ATS) to your load is one or the other supply, so no chance of grid export. In the case of true Off grid AIO's the ATS is incorporated into the box. The AIO's brain measures voltages, frequency and load and decides if either the grid or the PV/battery should be supplying the load. It can transfer fast because it monitors the AC signal and is ready for rapid transfer. A standard value is ~ 10ms.

Anytime the grid and the inverter shares a load (AC) it must be in parallel to do so. So if the grid picks up 100w and your PV inverter picks up 300w they are working together (in parallel) and spurious export can happen.

So you can run an off grid setup and supplement grid power you just can not supply the same loads from both grid and inverter at the same time. Typically folks use a critical load panel and/or additional transfer switches. Some power their Main panel with a breaker interlock setup or transfer switch like you would from an emergency generator.
 
It is a matter of understanding that supplying loads from your solar setup can work alongside the grid (not in parallel or grid tied) or it can work with the grid. For instance you can wire a standard DC to AC inverter directly to a load. It is not connected to the grid. No possibility of grid export exists. You can even wire that inverter to a transfer switch with one supply being the inverter and the alternative supply being the grid. From the Transfer switch (MTS or ATS) to your load is one or the other supply, so no chance of grid export. In the case of true Off grid AIO's the ATS is incorporated into the box. The AIO's brain measures voltages, frequency and load and decides if either the grid or the PV/battery should be supplying the load. It can transfer fast because it monitors the AC signal and is ready for rapid transfer. A standard value is ~ 10ms.

Anytime the grid and the inverter shares a load (AC) it must be in parallel to do so. So if the grid picks up 100w and your PV inverter picks up 300w they are working together (in parallel) and spurious export can happen.

So you can run an off grid setup and supplement grid power you just can not supply the same loads from both grid and inverter at the same time. Typically folks use a critical load panel and/or additional transfer switches. Some power their Main panel with a breaker interlock setup or transfer switch like you would from an emergency generator.
Any examples of what would cause a back feed on my off-grid AiO? This seems pretty interesting and since I have so many measuring devices on my home that should be able to measure down to 10mA I'd be interested and willing to experiment with my cheap Powmr AiO.
I can isolate the circuit it's being fed from and add loads so measurements would be possible, drop my telemetry down to 1s intervals, if I know the conditions I should be able to recreate them and see atleast if my system back feeds in anyway.
 
Any examples of what would cause a back feed on my off-grid AiO? This seems pretty interesting and since I have so many measuring devices on my home that should be able to measure down to 10mA I'd be interested and willing to experiment with my cheap Powmr AiO.
I can isolate the circuit it's being fed from and add loads so measurements would be possible, drop my telemetry down to 1s intervals, if I know the conditions I should be able to recreate them and see atleast if my system back feeds in anyway.
Examples often involved heavy inductive loads like transformers. In similar to the way that spark ignition works a collapsing magnetic field around a coil will induce a current. The other concern is speed of switching such that an inverter in parallel to grid carrying a portion of a load does not respond fast enough when load goes away and the level of production feeds back to grid. Example grid is carrying 100w of a 400w load, the grid tie is carrying 300w. The load shuts off and the grid and inverter has to balance out remaining loads. During this time the grid tie can export.
 
An off grid AIO won't/ can't backfeed the grid.
With one exception, SUB mode.
SUB mode allows the AIO to operate in parallel with the grid. And act like a hybrid AIO in zero export mode. It has the same advantages and disadvantages for that setup.
This type of function wasn't a problem until the utility meters became super sensitive to micro bursts of export.
 
Examples often involved heavy inductive loads like transformers. In similar to the way that spark ignition works a collapsing magnetic field around a coil will induce a current. The other concern is speed of switching such that an inverter in parallel to grid carrying a portion of a load does not respond fast enough when load goes away and the level of production feeds back to grid. Example grid is carrying 100w of a 400w load, the grid tie is carrying 300w. The load shuts off and the grid and inverter has to balance out remaining loads. During this time the grid tie can export.
Ok so lemme wrap my head around this as a test procedure large inductive load on the aio, drop grid tie, drop load, measure input of aio with loads on that input circuit? I'll have to fit a twin pole on the AIO radial I guess but it should be possible to attempt atleast
 
An off grid AIO won't/ can't backfeed the grid.
With one exception, SUB mode.
SUB mode allows the AIO to operate in parallel with the grid. And act like a hybrid AIO in zero export mode. It has the same advantages and disadvantages for that setup.
This type of function wasn't a problem until the utility meters became super sensitive to micro bursts of export.
Mines always in sub I think it's worth experimenting anyway even if the data has already been proven.
 
It is a matter of understanding that supplying loads from your solar setup can work alongside the grid (not in parallel or grid tied) or it can work with the grid. For instance you can wire a standard DC to AC inverter directly to a load. It is not connected to the grid. No possibility of grid export exists. You can even wire that inverter to a transfer switch with one supply being the inverter and the alternative supply being the grid. From the Transfer switch (MTS or ATS) to your load is one or the other supply, so no chance of grid export. In the case of true Off grid AIO's the ATS is incorporated into the box. The AIO's brain measures voltages, frequency and load and decides if either the grid or the PV/battery should be supplying the load. It can transfer fast because it monitors the AC signal and is ready for rapid transfer. A standard value is ~ 10ms.

Anytime the grid and the inverter shares a load (AC) it must be in parallel to do so. So if the grid picks up 100w and your PV inverter picks up 300w they are working together (in parallel) and spurious export can happen.

So you can run an off grid setup and supplement grid power you just can not supply the same loads from both grid and inverter at the same time. Typically folks use a critical load panel and/or additional transfer switches. Some power their Main panel with a breaker interlock setup or transfer switch like you would from an emergency generator.
So are you saying there is no way to have grid assist or blending or whatever nomenclature AND not have the potential to backfeed?

If that's the case then I will be forced to use an either/or type inverter meaning I use self gen until it can't provide enough then it switches to grid.
 
So are you saying there is no way to have grid assist or blending or whatever nomenclature AND not have the potential to backfeed?
Correct.
If that's the case then I will be forced to use an either/or type inverter meaning I use self gen until it can't provide enough then it switches to grid.
Just disconnect AC input from whatever inverter you want to use. Then hook a separate charger, like an EG4 Chargeverter onto your DC bus. Connect the charger to your grid AC. Now you can't backfeed, you have a dedicated, safe to use, 5000watt converted to DC grid feed. Only becomes an issue if 5000 watts, plus whatevers in your battery at the time isn't enough to power the loads of the inverter.
 
An off grid AIO won't/ can't backfeed the grid.
With one exception, SUB mode.
SUB mode allows the AIO to operate in parallel with the grid. And act like a hybrid AIO in zero export mode. It has the same advantages and disadvantages for that setup.
This type of function wasn't a problem until the utility meters became super sensitive to micro bursts of export.
I'm pretty sure I want SBU mode as I want to limit the power from the grid. Are you saying if I get an off-grid and use SBU mode that I would have no risk of export?
 
I'm pretty sure I want SBU mode as I want to limit the power from the grid. Are you saying if I get an off-grid and use SBU mode that I would have no risk of export?
Presumably, if it's designed properly and working correctly, yes. Safer to not have any AC hooked up to it at all though, and just use a Chargeverter if you are super paranoid about it.
 
Correct.

Just disconnect AC input from whatever inverter you want to use. Then hook a separate charger, like an EG4 Chargeverter onto your DC bus. Connect the charger to your grid AC. Now you can't backfeed, you have a dedicated, safe to use, 5000watt converted to DC grid feed. Only becomes an issue if 5000 watts, plus whatevers in your battery at the time isn't enough to power the loads of the inverter.
I think I can visualize what you're saying. This is that double conversion thing. So the charger would charge the battery using grid power and my inverter would take that power as necessary for my loads. My only limitation would be how much power my inverter can supply on the AC out side.
 
I'm pretty sure I want SBU mode as I want to limit the power from the grid. Are you saying if I get an off-grid and use SBU mode that I would have no risk of export?
No risk of exporting, in SBU mode. The inverter is never in parallel with the grid.
 
Ok so lemme wrap my head around this as a test procedure large inductive load on the aio, drop grid tie, drop load, measure input of aio with loads on that input circuit? I'll have to fit a twin pole on the AIO radial I guess but it should be possible to attempt atleast
I would be interested in how it turns out. Theory and in practice are not always equal. :)
 
I think I can visualize what you're saying. This is that double conversion thing. So the charger would charge the battery using grid power and my inverter would take that power as necessary for my loads. My only limitation would be how much power my inverter can supply on the AC out side.
Right. You are limited to whatever your inverter can actually generate, AC wise. The plus side is, you have a 100% always on UPS.. with zero switchover time. You also get to use solar and batteries all the time that they are available, regardless of what tiny amount of it is available.
 

diy solar

diy solar
Back
Top