NC_hydro
Solar Enthusiast
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2022
- Messages
- 295
I'd pick a quality box without remote monitoring vs a Beta Box with it.Fair enough, but any box without remote monitoring would be a non starter for me
I'd pick a quality box without remote monitoring vs a Beta Box with it.Fair enough, but any box without remote monitoring would be a non starter for me
Buy victron and get both- Quality box with great remote monitoring and controlI'd pick a quality box without remote monitoring vs a Beta Box with it.
Ha! Yes. Nothing about this project is undersized... I guess I meant undersized relatively speaking... 40 k+ PV is a lot!PV is so cheap and getting cheaper every day so oversize batteries AND PV if no generator.
Thank you. No permissions needed for anything (anything!). Installed our own septic, well, etc. Starlink, Solar, and partially underground...Depending on how leisurely or not the construction timeline is, I would consider not wasting time trying to build, troubleshoot, and operate a temporary or starter system. Just run a generator for your temporary power if you're allowed to.
If this is more like you're living on site in a camper, and building it at your own pace, then it's not out of the question that it makes sense though.
I have a 30kw array and could still use more for winter.Ha! Yes. Nothing about this project is undersized... I guess I meant undersized relatively speaking... 40 k+ PV is a lot!
Thank you. This is helpful. I was concerned about the entire battery bank bouncing between full and slightly discharged 90% of the time. The capacity calculation is to accommodate the 10% of the time everything will be on (at night).Why make it complicated. Short cycling LFP is not an issue. You could also just use a shunt and keep the battery between 20% and 80% or something. Personally, I don't bother: I built my place over the course of 5 years, the batteries were always there, and I just expanded over time as needed. That's one of the nice things about LFP: scale as you go.
I believe so.I would take the victron over the Rosie for surge as its an actual low frequency inverter but that's only a very small part of the whole system
- Can Rosie ac couple?
I think Dexter mentioned there's an app, but whether that ends up being as expansive as what VRM and VenusOS can deliver is unknown.
- Does Rosie have a portal where the owner can monitor his vacation house from his main house, like victron vrm?
Not sure if the app is local only or online via some portsl
- Can you change Rosie settings remotely? For example if owner needs to change settings on his charge controller?
I think so but probably not in the same league of configurabilty as Victron with ess assistants etc
- Does Rosie have ess capabilities? Eg peak shaving, zero export?
Less than that for Victron 10k which has been proven over many years.
- How much community support is available for Rosie
No and this is definitely a weakness versus the Quattro option. There was talk of just getting two in parallel working correctly which is a walk in the park for the blue.
- Are there any examples of large systems that have been done by Rosie? Eg 60-100kw?
might be using whizzbangjr
- How does Rosie handle SOC?
For the Rosie/Hawkes Bay/Barcelona they apparently all talk together via canbus. If you add an additional charger it will pick up the settings from the existing charger/network etc, which would be an improvement over Victron where you have to define the controller settings individually to match existing.
- Does Rosie talk seamlessly with other midnite components?
30W per the spec sheet:
- What is the idle draw of rosie
Interesting. I have not put much thought into sizing the PV array, given the low cost of PV capacity and the intended size of my battery bank.I have a 30kw array and could still use more for winter.
I have not put much thought into sizing the PV array
No. Unfortunately it is not.Ha! Yes. Nothing about this project is undersized... I guess I meant undersized relatively speaking... 40 k+ PV is a lot!
Strongly suggest separate building with climate control for your solar stuff/batteries. LFP chemistry is considered safe, but I wouldn't want to sit on that much power.I can install a 'permanent' electrical room underground now and add battery capacity i suppose.
Definitely hard to predict usage on new construction.Interesting. I have not put much thought into sizing the PV array, given the low cost of PV capacity and the intended size of my battery bank.
I'm in South Texas (Hill Country) but it is fairly cloudy much of the Winter. House heating won't be a major concern with thermal mass of underground construction and extensive insulation. But pumps/motors/etc always consume.
Given the potential for load requirements to expand significantly I would withdraw my Rosie suggestion and go with the 10kVA Quattro building blocks. The Rosie is advertised as suitable for "midsize" homes and this sounds like it's gonna be a monster.Buy victron and get both- Quality box with great remote monitoring and control
and I assumed I would get ridiculed for overkill...Definitely hard to predict usage on new construction.
I guess you won’t know until it’s done.
I just wouldn’t want you to get to December with no Grid or Generator then run out of power.
No Bueno..
You could win a big Powerball and we'd still easily spend it all on massive overkill.and I assumed I would get ridiculed for overkill...
Amen.I don't want roof penetrations
Thank you. I was considering this topic yesterday. My domestic breaker and manifolds will sit in a basement mechanical room. Batteries and RO water system will sit directly below this, in a -2 level basement. All 12" concrete with concrete suspended floor decks etc. Basically mechanical rooms are concrete vaults. Steady temp, & gravity floor drains. It fire suppression is low priority, wondering if ventilation plan might be useful?Strongly suggest separate building with climate control for your solar stuff/batteries. LFP chemistry is considered safe, but I wouldn't want to sit on that much power
Maybe but your situation is a little different.and I assumed I would get ridiculed for overkill...
Yeah I like your initial suggestion best. Stacking 10kva quattrosGiven the potential for load requirements to expand significantly I would withdraw my Rosie suggestion and go with the 10kVA Quattro building blocks. The Rosie is advertised as suitable for "midsize" homes and this sounds like it's gonna be a monster.
I (will) have poured concrete roofs with a TPO layer on top (belt and suspenders for a DIY job). Solar 'boots' will be mechanically fastened to the concrete roof deck, with welded TPO boots surrounding them. Something of a direct attachement / ballast hybrid in that the mounts are firmly attached, but there are not penetrations through the roof itself. I've not done a TPO roof before, but have some contacts for help.Amen.
Ever since I got some roofing knowledge myself and did some roofs on outbuildings, I will forever avoid extra penetrations a dwelling roof if at all possible. Outbuildings where there's less at risk and I can directly monitor the underside of the sheathing, then it's tolerable.