diy solar

diy solar

2 4S LIFEP04 packs in parallel, 2 BMS's

wntrhwk

New Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2020
Messages
96
Hello, I heard that having 2 4s packs in parallel, each with a BMS, is not the best configuration. I have read that there can be a feedback or surge situation that can take out one of the BMS's. Anyone have any info on this setup?
 
Hello, I heard that having 2 4s packs in parallel, each with a BMS, is not the best configuration. I have read that there can be a feedback or surge situation that can take out one of the BMS's. Anyone have any info on this setup?

You have heard wrong unless it was specific to the initial act of connecting the two batteries together. You want the voltage within 0.2V to prevent a surge that will potentially activate short circuit protection on one or both BMS. "take out" a BMS would be exceedingly abnormal. Once in parallel PROPERLY (see link #6 in my signature), should be no issues.
 
You have heard wrong unless it was specific to the initial act of connecting the two batteries together. You want the voltage within 0.2V to prevent a surge that will potentially activate short circuit protection on one or both BMS. "take out" a BMS would be exceedingly abnormal. Once in parallel PROPERLY (see link #6 in my signature), should be no issues.
Good info Sunshine, thx. I had a BMS on one pack fail after discharging 30amps., guess I need to pay attention to my initial setup. Still kinda new to all the subtleties with proper battery configs.
 
Hello, I heard that having 2 4s packs in parallel, each with a BMS, is not the best configuration. I have read that there can be a feedback or surge situation that can take out one of the BMS's. Anyone have any info on this setup?
What Eggo said. Having batteries in parallel gives you two advantages. First it spreads the draw across dual BMS and battery sets so each one isn't having to work as hard, and second (as you've seen) if one dies you're not in the dark while you're trying to fix the system.
When you say the pack failed after 30a, like it smoked and died or just acted like it was dead? What happens if you try to charge it alone and run a load off it?

Always best practice to have both batteries charged to the same voltage before you connect them together or the higher charge battery will try to charge the lower battery all at once and can pop your BMS. Usually you can just throw them on a charger and it'll wake up the tripped battery and balance the batteries as they charge.
 
Thx for the replies, I guess I may have just had a bad BMS. Couldn't get to to wake no matter what I tried.
 
Thx for the replies, I guess I may have just had a bad BMS. Couldn't get to to wake no matter what I tried.
Just out of morbid curiosity, when you unplug the balance lead jack from the BMS, what voltage do you get on the cell pack itself? Plugging the balance leads back in with more than 10v on the pack should reset/reawaken it. If that doesn't happen, hopefully a BMS swap is fairly easy.
 
on the pack I was getting 13.3v, with the balance leads connected I only got 10.9 at P-
 
Back
Top