The problem is that you're fried your BatteryProtect. I'm the Technical Support Manager for the largest stocking Victron distributor in the western US, and this is a problem I've seen countless times because Victron doesn't make one thing clear in their documentation: The BatteryProtect is unidirectional in operation ONLY... it cannot be connected in a way that allows reverse current through it -ie, it cannot be connected between a battery and a busbar to which any charge source is also connected (your solar charger, for instance, or an alternator, or any other charge source). Applying reverse current to it will almost instantly fry the FETs; usually they'll weld closed, permitting full current throughput but won't ever disconnect the load; sometimes they'll weld open, so no current is passed through in any case; and sometimes some of them weld shut and others weld open, in which case you see the condition you're describing: the ones welded shut are passing current while the ones welded open are not, so you end up with weird voltages on the other side.