diy solar

diy solar

Solar Panel Location with respect to the Sun

Jim Burrow

Solar Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 27, 2020
Messages
516
First please excuse me if I lose you as everyone knows how bad engineers can screw up a document written by them. Next, note that I added a pdf below in case the article is too long to read in the forum.

Background – My (6) 300W Solar panels are to be mounted on top of my covered carport roof. - mounting on top of the house roof is out of the question.

The panels will lay halfway down the roof with the lengths facing toward the house and with a distributed weight of 240 lbs. over a 90 sq. ft. area. The panel labeled (A) and is “colored blue” in the image, is slanted down -11 degrees from Horizontal and the panel labeled (B) and “colored red” in the image is slanted up by 11 degrees from the horizontal line. – Note: the panels in the image are the theoretical locations and to be determined for the best angle.

Testing – The goal for the next two weeks (beginning 1 Oct 2020), is to measure how many Lumens and the percentage of lumens will reach the solar panels to produce maximum energy with respect to the sun location in the sky and its output lumens of 16,384 as measured with my meter. I would start my measurements at 8 am first light on the panels and until 5 pm, where the sun is looking right on the side edge of the panels as seen in the image. I did this all day, every hour for 2 weeks.

Measurements - I would measure the Sun declination and Azimuth and the lumens of the sun and lumens shining on the panels for three different theoretical angles of the panels every hour with respect to the horizontal line. Note the actual panels were not used nor mounted on the carport roof as of this testing. - That is why I say theoretical. I built a tool to do all the measurements with respect to the 3 different panel angles.

Analysis – The testing went for two weeks and to my surprise, when the sun was the highest point in the sky, between noon and 1:00 pm and an angle of 40 degrees, and pointing directly at the surface of the panes, the panel that was slanted down -11 degrees, was only getting 35% of the total sun lumens of 16384. – what a bummer!

But rising my theoretical panels up 22 degrees (+11 degrees about the horizontal line/plan) the panels received 100% of the suns lumens from 10:00 AM to 3:00 PM and by 4:00 PM, the lumens were down to 27% of the suns total lumens of 16384 all day long.

It looks like I will not be able to lay the panels flat on the top of the carport roof. To get the maximum 100% sun lumens from 10:00 AM to 3:00 PM, I will need to angle my panels at point (A) up by 22 degrees or 11 degrees above the horizontal line. – final position of the panel (B).

With respect to the Sun, the highest point in the sky was only 40 degrees above the horizontal line between noon and 1:00 PM here in the San Francisco bay area at the beginning of October 2020.

With respect to the house, all “but”, the Microwave receptacle, clothes washer, and dryer plus the Air Conditioner will be powered by the Solar/Utility/Gas Generator/ battery combination controlled by my MPP 2424LV-MDS. The items not powered by Solar will stay on Utility 100% of the time by dividing my sub-panel circuit breaker box into two isolated halves. One half will always be connected to the Utility company and the other half will be connected to the 2424lv controller 120vac output port by adding a white common return wire to the left side of the box.

By using a separate utility/gas/2424LV power distribution box that I built, ties everything together via 3 100-amp DBDT switches to provide power to the left side of the breaker box. In case the 2424LV controller goes out, I can still power the whole house on utility company or by a Gas Generator by repositioning the 3 switches.

The house power during the afternoon typically uses 400w to 600w and in the mornings around 350 watts and after I go to bed, the power drops down to around 150 watts until I get back up the next morning.

So, I got my work cut out for me in making mounting brackets for my solar panels to have an elevation of 11 degrees about horizontal. I also need to add louvers to the mounting brackets to direct the wind-down as not to try and left the panels up during high winds. – Although high winds in my area never get above 25 mph and on average less than 10 mph.

1603661473656.png
 

Attachments

  • Solar Panel position with respect to the Sun.pdf
    146.7 KB · Views: 9
Either this is just too long, or it seems overly complicated.

The movement of the sun doesn't make sense. Sun moves east to west, not south to north.

Your panels should be facing due south as much as possible.

Your panels should be tilted towards the south by:


Anything less, and you're leaving Wh on the table.
 
10 deg is actually a good angle for panels on fixed roofs because it allows good water drainage reducing cleaning needs and doesn’t cause any shading issues allowing maximum panel coverage.
 
Either this is just too long, or it seems overly complicated.

The movement of the sun doesn't make sense. Sun moves east to west, not south to north.

Your panels should be facing due south as much as possible.

Your panels should be tilted towards the south by:


Anything less, and you're leaving Wh on the table.
if you look at the image at the top left you will see the orientation of the panels. they are facing south. With respect to the sun, it does move across the sky from east to west. Note that I added a pdf knowing that the article is too long for some people.

This is nothing more but a show and tells of the tested I did to find the best angle for my solar panels with respect to the sun as it crosses the sky where I live. I have noticed there have been posts from people asking where to place their panels for maximum power output.

Anyway, sorry for the show and tell. In the future, I will only ask questions and not give reports on my process of building my system and the testing involved.
 
I was making an observation. I didn't dislike anything. I'm just concerned that your conclusion of a 22° panel tilt from the carport is going to miss a lot of solar.

I tend to start with known best practices, see if I can accommodate it and then revise it as needed.
 
I think tilt becomes more important in the winter and the higher the latitude you are. Often in places like the UK it will double your winter PV output. Having said that 2x ‘not a lot’ is still not a lot.
 
Off angle hits you no matter where you are really. It doesn't take much to knock an easy 15% off the production. If the panels are fixed it's going to be a compromise because of the changing track of the sun as the seasons pass. The only people that really get away with no appreciable difference are +/-10 degrees from the equator. I'm at 21S and there's a fair amount of seasonal variation in peak power.
 
Don’t apologise just because one person didn’t like the detail. There will be plenty who will find it interesting and appreciate it
Thanks. I've always liked sharing my adventures and test results as I test everything. If I didn't test for the best sun angle for my panels with respect to where I wanted to locate them, I would have made a big mistake and would have ended up only getting 35% of the sun's lumens. - And not being a happy camper.
 
Lots of readily available resources for this that negate the need for any experimentation and produce more useful results. These data sources also provide considerations for average weather conditions as well. It also factors in a 15% inefficiency between solar collected and AC power provided.

Here's your 1800W system with -11° panels in the San Fran area:

1603739410832.png

Here's your system with +11°:

1603739460044.png

MAJOR performance hits in the winter - 50% loss.

Here you are for an optimal 32° tilt:

1603739576430.png

Net annual production is only mildly higher, but the cooler months get more at a slight expense to the warmer months.

When plotted against one another, it looks like this:

1603739987892.png
 
You can test quite a lot, but why not rely to professional expertise?
PVGIS will do the math for you and deliver free of charge and at a breeze what you would take years to find out.

What is your aim: get the max power in summer since you can back-feed to the grid, or get the most regular energy over the year?, maximizing your winter production? All that will impact your optimum panel slope.
Additionally: do you have to plan with snow?
If yes, think to elevate your panel so that a sliding snow blanket will not accumulate in front of the panel,
 
You can test quite a lot, but why not rely to professional expertise?
PVGIS will do the math for you and deliver free of charge and at a breeze what you would take years to find out.

What is your aim: get the max power in summer since you can back-feed to the grid, or get the most regular energy over the year?, maximizing your winter production? All that will impact your optimum panel slope.
Additionally: do you have to plan with snow?
If yes, think to elevate your panel so that a sliding snow blanket will not accumulate in front of the panel,

San Fran Bay area averages 0.0 in of snow per year.
 
Guys I think some maybe missing the point

Yes there are resources that can give some info but this whole forum is a lot about working out how to do stuff ourselves and sharing that info.

By going through a DIY measuring process the OP will have learnt racks about how the sun shines at his location and by sharing the info everyone can share the learning too.
 
You can test quite a lot, but why not rely to professional expertise?
PVGIS will do the math for you and deliver free of charge and at a breeze what you would take years to find out.

What is your aim: get the max power in summer since you can back-feed to the grid, or get the most regular energy over the year?, maximizing your winter production? All that will impact your optimum panel slope.
Additionally: do you have to plan with snow?
If yes, think to elevate your panel so that a sliding snow blanket will not accumulate in front of the panel,
I am limited to space where I can put my panels. I wanted to lay them on my carport cover. But I was curious if I would get enough energy (in terms of lumens) throughout the day to run my power needs in the house and charge a battery. - It turns out that I can not. I need to tilt one end up so more lumens can shine in them. I'm also restricted to how much of a tilt I can have with respect to cosmetics. If the angle is too great, the park where I live will not allow me to install the panels.

No, spect sheet in the world can tell me that information with respect to my specific location. That is why I did the testing. As an engineer, I am quite capable of running the testing I needed.

I only posted my testing and analysis as there have been questions on the solar panel locations in the past from the group. I thought it would be of some interest to some folks. But it looks like I was wrong. - OOPs!

Anyway, I really appreciate your input and data spect sheets. Found them interesting and for most people all they would ever need. - Thanks again for your reply.
 
You can test quite a lot, but why not rely to professional expertise?
PVGIS will do the math for you and deliver free of charge and at a breeze what you would take years to find out.

What is your aim: get the max power in summer since you can back-feed to the grid, or get the most regular energy over the year?, maximizing your winter production? All that will impact your optimum panel slope.
Additionally: do you have to plan with snow?
If yes, think to elevate your panel so that a sliding snow blanket will not accumulate in front of the panel,
Snow! what here in the S.F. bay area where the temperature in this valley in the winter never gets below 45F degrees. The last time I saw snow here was back in 1975 and that was a freak winter and only lasted for one day. I need to angle my panels not for snowpack build up but to get enough sunlight on the panels to power my house.
 
Guys I think some maybe missing the point

Yes there are resources that can give some info but this whole forum is a lot about working out how to do stuff ourselves and sharing that info.

By going through a DIY measuring process the OP will have learnt racks about how the sun shines at his location and by sharing the info everyone can share the learning too.
I thought that was the purpose of the show and tell section of the forum. Not to ask questions, but to show off your work, progress, and anything else you are proud of. To my understanding, it is not meant to ask questions.
 
Show & Tell used to imply you are open to questions about what you did and how you did it, ie the tell part. Perhaps that has changed.
 
Snow! what here in the S.F. bay area where the temperature in this valley in the winter never gets below 45F degrees. The last time I saw snow here was back in 1975 and that was a freak winter and only lasted for one day. I need to angle my panels not for snowpack build up but to get enough sunlight on the panels to power my house.
You didn't tell where you are, it was just an eventuality.
What about the other questions?
 
Back
Top