Hedges
I See Electromagnetic Fields!
- Joined
- Mar 28, 2020
- Messages
- 20,681
Thanks, so I guess more specifically one or more of the REC-BMS Q-BMS 16S, depending on how large a battery bank I want to build?
Man, this sure is starting to add up...
And that doesn't include external contactor or pre-charge accessory.
Of course, you can assemble 16s2p battery with two BMS, or 2p16s with one BMS.
Many people here have parallel/series battery packs. Series/parallel may be more ideal for protection. If one parallel connection went bad, the remaining cell would carry 2x current, but BMS would only know current of whole pack. If total pack current was 1/2 max allowed charge and discharge, maybe not a huge problem. BMS would observe that cell going over/under voltage and would tell SI to reduce current (balance during charge) or shut off (to avoid over-discharge.)
I think if you buy $8k or $14k worth of inverters you can afford $750 worth of BMS. Cost starts to bite if you need BMS for three separate battery strings on a 2x SI system.
I went with 20 kWh of SunXtender AGM (on 4x SI system) because it is occasional grid-backup. At the time (2 years ago) the alternative I was aware of was LG RESU, 5x the price for 5x the cycle life. That has since been subject to recalls due to fires. Today, DIY with 280 Ah cells and REC is around half the price, has similar usable capacity (compared to 70% DoD of my lead-acid.) BMS adding 25% on top of cost of cells.
It is similar with cost of PV. The panels have come down 10x over 20 years, but rack mounting has gone up, can dominate the cost. So yeah it's expensive, but is part of a well designed, well integrated system.
There are server rack batteries, I think almost twice the price for under half the capacity, but claimed twice the cycle life.
"Server Rack", meaning intended to provide 48VDC to computer servers. Some reportedly perform better than others with precharge inrush and high inverter loads. You end up needing multiple in parallel to handle the current. "Some" brands, in some installations the customer never gets it to work (shuts off.) Some customers have to replace with a different brand. Some open it up and replace with a better (but still inexpensive) BMS.
Other brands of inverters may have been configured for communications with some brands of server rack batteries. Many I think are used without communications. I don't have first-hand experience with either SI or other inverters on lithium.