diy solar

diy solar

Struggling with battery capacity

wgrippo

New Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2021
Messages
89
Hi,

I'm trying to understand why my off-grid system has not been making it through the night, hoping some of you solar sleuths can help me out. I built this system in the spring and it did well for a while with batteries rarely dropping below 75%, but for the past month or so the inverter has been shutting down due to low voltage early in the morning. If we run the generator in the evening for a couple hours it helps, but even then we drop way down in voltage overnight.

I've contacted the seller of the batteries, and he says we simply need more batteries. I contacted Growatt, and they took a look at my settings and say everything is fine. But what I don't understand is why the power we are using doesn't even come close to the amp-hour rating of the batteries.

We have 4500W of panels, Growatt SPF6000 Inverter/Controller, and eight "lead-carbon" AGM 12V batteries. The batteries are rated at 250Ah (at 77°F). I am running two parallel strings of four batteries, so 48V and 500 Ah. I ran the 240V output from the inverter directly into my electrical panel, and all circuits in the house are brand new and working great.

The controller is set to charge to 56V, and then float at 54V. Looking at my data from yesterday, the battery voltage reached 56V by 10:30am, and stayed there for two hours until 12:30pm, when it dropped to 54V. It stayed right around 54V until around 5pm when the sun gets low in the sky, and from there the voltage starts to drop. I'm assuming that when they go to 54V they are full and under float charge...?

Looking at our power usage, from 5pm until 3:30am when the inverter shut down we are using between 200W and 350W, which is two ceiling fans, the TV for a while, the fridge cycling on and off, some lights, wifi modem, and other small electronics. The battery voltage drops from 54V at 5pm to 52V at 6pm, 51V at 9pm, and then rapidly to 46V at midnight. It continues to fall until 3:30am, when it gets to 42.5V and the inverter shuts down.

Attached are plots of battery voltage and power usage from yesterday and this morning.

Now for my calculations. If I have 500 Ah of capacity at 48V, that is 24,000 Wh. I understand that we don't really want to use more than 50% of the battery capacity, so I should safely have 12,000 Wh to use before the batteries drop to 50%, of course a bit less than that due to inverter efficiency, etc.

So I'm using lets say 350W max for 10.5 hours, which is 3,675 W-hr of energy. So why are my batteries dropping down to under 25% when I'm not using anywhere near the energy I have?? I'm a mechanical engineer, not electrical (haha), but the math is pretty simple, right?

I understand this is not an exact science, and battery capacity can vary with temperature and other factors. My battery room is in the low 80 degrees F for most of this time.

Any thoughts? Am I missing something?
 
It would be nice if you had a way to accurately measure the current in and out of the pack.

How old are the batteries? Kinda sounds like they are failing .... and if they keep being discharged to the point where the inverter shuts down they are being damaged even more.
 
Last edited:
It would be nice if you had a way to accurately measure the current in and out of the pack.

How old are the batteries? Kinda sounds like they are failing .... and if they keep being discharged to the point where the inverter shuts down they are being damaged even more.
I just measured current in and out of the batteries (while charging), right now it is 10A.

The batteries were new in March this year. I know it's not good to let them get that low! It has happened that many times yet, but I will start turning off more breakers in the evening until I get this sorted. We really just need one ceiling fan at night to sleep in the summer.
 
I do like the idea of measuring the individual battery voltages - will do that this afternoon (my wife needs the power on to work right now)...
 
I do like the idea of measuring the individual battery voltages - will do that this afternoon (my wife needs the power on to work right now)...
You can probably see if any are fubar while they are being used, especially if you are experiencing under-voltage. A bad battery will be drawn down an exaggerated amount which may be more revealing.
The most accurate measurement will be at rest.
 
FWIW, here are the current voltages (while charging via PV).
PXL_20210901_183714256.jpg
 
The batteries are sold by a company here in Baja, Mexico called Green Energy Systems. They really try to sell the AGM Lead-Carbon thing, and have installed them all around the area we live. I didn't use them for the install as I did it myself, but I did buy the batteries from them. I suspect they are buying the from alibaba.com and importing them in bulk into Mexico. Here are the specs:

240406298_275627140738631_1605964437639141945_n.jpg

237105329_825026555047910_4159932503582892450_n.jpg
 
The one point they really try to drive home is the batteries need to stay cool. They even came to inspect my battery room to make sure I had installed a mini-split AC and insulation before selling them to me. We do keep the AC running (only the summer months) to keep the batteries at about 78F all day. As the sun sets we turn the AC off, but the insulation really keeps the room cool, rising to max 85F overnight (depending on outside temp).
 
I just measured current in and out of the batteries (while charging), right now it is 10A.
I was talking about some sort of shunt .... like the Victron Smart shunt that would let you know exactly how much power you are putting in and getting out of your batteries .... and maybe test the batteries individually as you are planning to do with voltage checks.
Now that I think about it, not sure if the Smart Shunt is good for 48 V .... probably is, but I am just using that as an example. There are a large variety of shunt type monitors on the market.
 
Well my controller/inverter gives out a lot of info. Charge power, power consumed, PV volts, PV power, etc. All can be plotted vs time of day.
 
Have you tested individual voltages immediately after inverter shut off? If it is a battery issue, you should see an outlier here.
 
Have you tested individual voltages immediately after inverter shut off? If it is a battery issue, you should see an outlier here.
Yea, its looking like the 13.75, 13.88 and 13.92 are suspect. With PV charge being applied, they are likely propped up. But once charging is removed and a load applied, they may drop and reveal some problems (my guess anyway).
 
I wonder if you could swap batteries around, put the lower voltage batteries in a single string, try and bring just them up to proper charge voltage, then repair with the second string, and kind of poor mans top balance?
 
Hi,

I'm trying to understand why my off-grid system has not been making it through the night, hoping some of you solar sleuths can help me out. I built this system in the spring and it did well for a while with batteries rarely dropping below 75%, but for the past month or so the inverter has been shutting down due to low voltage early in the morning. If we run the generator in the evening for a couple hours it helps, but even then we drop way down in voltage overnight.

I've contacted the seller of the batteries, and he says we simply need more batteries. I contacted Growatt, and they took a look at my settings and say everything is fine. But what I don't understand is why the power we are using doesn't even come close to the amp-hour rating of the batteries.

We have 4500W of panels, Growatt SPF6000 Inverter/Controller, and eight "lead-carbon" AGM 12V batteries. The batteries are rated at 250Ah (at 77°F). I am running two parallel strings of four batteries, so 48V and 500 Ah. I ran the 240V output from the inverter directly into my electrical panel, and all circuits in the house are brand new and working great.

The controller is set to charge to 56V, and then float at 54V. Looking at my data from yesterday, the battery voltage reached 56V by 10:30am, and stayed there for two hours until 12:30pm, when it dropped to 54V. It stayed right around 54V until around 5pm when the sun gets low in the sky, and from there the voltage starts to drop. I'm assuming that when they go to 54V they are full and under float charge...?

Looking at our power usage, from 5pm until 3:30am when the inverter shut down we are using between 200W and 350W, which is two ceiling fans, the TV for a while, the fridge cycling on and off, some lights, wifi modem, and other small electronics. The battery voltage drops from 54V at 5pm to 52V at 6pm, 51V at 9pm, and then rapidly to 46V at midnight. It continues to fall until 3:30am, when it gets to 42.5V and the inverter shuts down.

Attached are plots of battery voltage and power usage from yesterday and this morning.

Now for my calculations. If I have 500 Ah of capacity at 48V, that is 24,000 Wh. I understand that we don't really want to use more than 50% of the battery capacity, so I should safely have 12,000 Wh to use before the batteries drop to 50%, of course a bit less than that due to inverter efficiency, etc.

So I'm using lets say 350W max for 10.5 hours, which is 3,675 W-hr of energy. So why are my batteries dropping down to under 25% when I'm not using anywhere near the energy I have?? I'm a mechanical engineer, not electrical (haha), but the math is pretty simple, right?

I understand this is not an exact science, and battery capacity can vary with temperature and other factors. My battery room is in the low 80 degrees F for most of this time.

Any thoughts? Am I missing something?
1st the obvious (which sounds like u r aware), batteries being lead so check fluid level (dont remember if sealed).

Ur aware of temp affect on batteries so thats ruled out.

Personally, I would test wattage consumption over early am interval... narrow down if something is odd (like something suddenly pulling too much).

Going straight to battery thoughts cuz it really appears issue is there.

Btw, threw ur math or setup description threw mr. You said 2 strings of 4 12v/250ah in parallel. Did I read that correctly?

Did u mean 2 strings of 4 12v/250ah in series (becomes 48v/250ah each string) THEN parallel (becomes 48v/500ah in total). Provides 24,000wh which is plenty then some... of course with everything properly functioning.

I assume u know how to test batteries? Either bad cells or something draining them.
 
The one point they really try to drive home is the batteries need to stay cool. They even came to inspect my battery room to make sure I had installed a mini-split AC and insulation before selling them to me. We do keep the AC running (only the summer months) to keep the batteries at about 78F all day. As the sun sets we turn the AC off, but the insulation really keeps the room cool, rising to max 85F overnight (depending on outside temp).
Hi,

I'm trying to understand why my off-grid system has not been making it through the night, hoping some of you solar sleuths can help me out. I built this system in the spring and it did well for a while with batteries rarely dropping below 75%, but for the past month or so the inverter has been shutting down due to low voltage early in the morning. If we run the generator in the evening for a couple hours it helps, but even then we drop way down in voltage overnight.

I've contacted the seller of the batteries, and he says we simply need more batteries. I contacted Growatt, and they took a look at my settings and say everything is fine. But what I don't understand is why the power we are using doesn't even come close to the amp-hour rating of the batteries.

We have 4500W of panels, Growatt SPF6000 Inverter/Controller, and eight "lead-carbon" AGM 12V batteries. The batteries are rated at 250Ah (at 77°F). I am running two parallel strings of four batteries, so 48V and 500 Ah. I ran the 240V output from the inverter directly into my electrical panel, and all circuits in the house are brand new and working great.

The controller is set to charge to 56V, and then float at 54V. Looking at my data from yesterday, the battery voltage reached 56V by 10:30am, and stayed there for two hours until 12:30pm, when it dropped to 54V. It stayed right around 54V until around 5pm when the sun gets low in the sky, and from there the voltage starts to drop. I'm assuming that when they go to 54V they are full and under float charge...?

Looking at our power usage, from 5pm until 3:30am when the inverter shut down we are using between 200W and 350W, which is two ceiling fans, the TV for a while, the fridge cycling on and off, some lights, wifi modem, and other small electronics. The battery voltage drops from 54V at 5pm to 52V at 6pm, 51V at 9pm, and then rapidly to 46V at midnight. It continues to fall until 3:30am, when it gets to 42.5V and the inverter shuts down.

Attached are plots of battery voltage and power usage from yesterday and this morning.

Now for my calculations. If I have 500 Ah of capacity at 48V, that is 24,000 Wh. I understand that we don't really want to use more than 50% of the battery capacity, so I should safely have 12,000 Wh to use before the batteries drop to 50%, of course a bit less than that due to inverter efficiency, etc.

So I'm using lets say 350W max for 10.5 hours, which is 3,675 W-hr of energy. So why are my batteries dropping down to under 25% when I'm not using anywhere near the energy I have?? I'm a mechanical engineer, not electrical (haha), but the math is pretty simple, right?

I understand this is not an exact science, and battery capacity can vary with temperature and other factors. My battery room is in the low 80 degrees F for most of this time.

Any thoughts? Am I missing something?
Btw u didnt mention where u were, specifically humidity level. Im in insanely high humidity. IE) last night temp had dropped but humidity woke me 3 times. Was horrible! Pt is: humidity level as much as temp damages batteries.


 
1st the obvious (which sounds like u r aware), batteries being lead so check fluid level (dont remember if sealed).

Did u mean 2 strings of 4 12v/250ah in series (becomes 48v/250ah each string) THEN parallel (becomes 48v/500ah in total). Provides 24,000wh which is plenty then some... of course with everything properly functioning.
They are sealed, AGM.

Yes, 2 strings of 4 12v/250ah in series, then parallel becomes 48v/500ah total, 24,000 Wh.

I think that should be plenty if I could actually get that performance!
 
anadiner, I didn't realize humidity had an effect. We are in San Felipe, Baja California, Mexico, 3 hours south of US border, right on the beach on the Sea of Cortez. 9 months out of the year we are dry desert and moderate temps, but in the summer the sea heats up and we are mostly between 65% and 80% humidity and temp in the 90s. But these are sealed batteries - what part of the system does humidity affect?
 
Back
Top