diy solar

diy solar

Odd voltages from utility, help me understand what happened

n2aws

Solar Addict
Joined
Oct 24, 2022
Messages
681
Hey all,

I thought I had a pretty solid understanding of "split-phase 240v", grounds and neutrals, bonding.. etc.

However, about 2 months ago, my father in law had an issue I tried to help him with. First, the TL;DR, and then more details:


From the utility, I saw 120v on L1. I also saw 120v on L2. However, between L1 and L2, I saw 17v.

The longer version: FIL knows I've been doing a DIY solar build. He called me up saying that all the lights, refrigerators, etc worked in his house.. but his well pump, Central A/C, and oven weren't working.
Even before I got to his house, I suspected it was something to do with the 240v, and maybe one of the "hots" was dead, allowing some 120v stuff to work, but not 240v.

I get to his house, and break out the multimeter. After tracing the problem up (started at his subpanel with those loads). it turns out that on the mains into his main panel, I saw full voltage on *either* leg to ground. But when testing hot to hot, it was 17v.

He called the utility, and they dispatched a crew. A little later, the next door neighbor called and asked him if he had power. Turns out, they were having the same issue. Utility came out, and I told the guy who I saw first what troubleshooting I had done. He simply said "Hmm, sounds like a hot is burned out somewhere" but gave no further explanation. I left before they really got started (I had other plans, and needed to go)

It's been almost 2 months. They have not fixed whatever the original problem was, but instead, ran "temporary" wiring that is just laying on the ground in his driveway, from the transformer on a nearby pole.. to his meter box. Its a good thing they were able to do the temporary wiring though, cuz 2 months without A/C or water would be horrible anywhere, but especially in florida summer.

So, how the heck do 2 legs that seem to test ok at 120v each, result in 17v between them. is this an "out of phase" scenario?
 
When one leg goes down. The other leg can backfeed that leg, through any and all 240v connected loads.
Interesting, this had never even occurred to me.

Though, at initial thought, I guess I still don't understand why you wouldn't see 120v, if it was backfeeding to the other leg. Would this have to do with resistance through those 240v devices? Some kind of draw/voltage drop as the 240v stuff was trying to draw power to start/work/whatever?
 
Also, the 17v reading is the voltage drop between the two.
And you answered my question as I was typing it.

Thanks for the info, I'll need to read up on this a bit more. As I said, I hadn't even considered backfeeding.


So theoretically, if the people in all affected houses (2 in this case) had turned off the breakers for all 240v devices, we would have seen what? 0v across the 2, since there would have been no place for the current to go? (ie, incomplete circuit)
 
I'm not buying an open neutral type situation because both homes would have blown many 120v appliances.
However I cannot comprehend a situation where both legs ended up almost being connected directly.
 
Back
Top