I admit to being amused by threads such as these.
We have, as shining examples of modern customer service, Comcast and Amazon. In my myriad of interactions with Comcast, Amazon, and Signature solar, SS clearly comes out on top. I get to actually communicate with real people who actually have real power. If I can get connected to customer service at Comcast or Amazon, they follow the same exact script the website/phone system forced me through before I even had the chance to communicate with another human, and then their options are only slightly more expansive than the automated options for resolution. Amazon, for all its warts, always does fine by me as the customer, but I'd hate to be on the business side of the equation because like credit card companies, ebay, paypal, etc Amazon will always side with the buyer.
I recently placed two orders to Digikey within a few hours of each other, and one was cancelled with the notice going to spam. When I talked to them - and like SS they actually have real customer service people located in the US who aren't following a set-in-stone script - they indicated it was fraud management, and between me and them we resolved the issue and I received the order on time. I only contacted them because I had a deadline and was watching for the shipment notification, contacting them once I realized there was an issue - and finding they would not have done anything further beyond the email notice. If I had waited until delivery was expected I would have been in a difficult position.
None of this is new, this particular instance of misapplication of fraud protection isn't special or notable. The response from the company - be it via email, phone, text, or just waiting for the customer to call for an order update - isn't good or bad. The problem with high volume businesses is that the fraud notices are NOT handled by humans. It happens, the system updates the order, sends out an email, and that's it. They can't possibly try 3+ different contact methods for every fraud test positive they receive. If you have difficulty putting as much attention toward their emails as you put toward the ordering process, you're likely to be bitten by this problem repeatedly.
The frequency and value of fraud is accelerating at a staggering pace, and businesses are barely keeping up. It's not surprising that, in this example, the bank first threw a fraud warning and declined the transaction, only to have the company's fraud flag trigger and decline the transaction a second time. The only difference between the two is that one happened during the ordering process when the customer's attention was on the order, and the second when the customer's attention was not on the order. Personally I'd rather have a higher bar for fraud detection and suffer fewer fraudulent charges than the opposite, so whenever this happens to me rather than becoming angry I choose to be grateful that my finances are being well protected.
And for all that SS is throwing an impressive amount of resources towards this one customer and one transaction.
My son recently ran over an amazon box placed directly in front of the garage door. While he was absolutely right that amazon shouldn't have put it there, we also both now circle the car after opening the garage door and before getting in the driver's seat.
It's not that we think Amazon is faultless, but we see how large they are, and how inconsequential this one thing is to them, and rather than spending time going through a complaint process and delaying receipt of items we've ordered by days, we spend a few more seconds doing something that is overall safer anyway - toys, animals, and other items not placed by amazon have been noted and dealt with since we've adopted this strategy. It's no pre-flight checklist, but it's saved us a surprising amount of unhappiness and grief, and is well worth the effort.
I make mistakes, and I'd guess I make more of them, per mistake opportunity, than SS. If I had to perform thousands of actions a year, and each action involved 20+ steps and I made as few mistakes as SS does I'd count myself lucky. Meanwhile they're still examining their processes, getting feedback from customers who've suffered those mistakes, and then making improvements to reduce the error rate even further. On top of that they're paying particular attention to this forum and seeking out bad customer reports and pro-actively resolving them. Is there any forum where you can go complain about comcast or amazon and receive personalized help within a day, if not within hours?